scan-category-c.md (1424B)
1 # Scan Category C: Claims & Evidence + Limitations & Scope 2 3 **Model: Opus** 4 5 You are a category evaluator. Answer ONLY the questions in your assigned categories. 6 7 ## Your categories (7 questions) 8 9 ### Claims and Evidence (5q) 10 - `abstract_claims_supported` — abstract claims supported by results? 11 - `causal_claims_justified` — causal claims backed by adequate study design? 12 - `generalization_bounded` — generalizations bounded to tested setting? 13 - `alternative_explanations_discussed` — alternative explanations considered? 14 - `proxy_outcome_distinction` — does the paper distinguish what it measured from what it claims? 15 16 ### Limitations and Scope (3q) 17 - `limitations_section_present` — dedicated limitations section? 18 - `threats_to_validity_specific` — specific (not boilerplate) threats discussed? 19 - `scope_boundaries_stated` — explicit statements of what results do NOT show? 20 21 ## Input 22 23 1. Paper text: `papers/<SLUG>/paper.txt` 24 2. Triage applicability flags: `papers/<SLUG>/triage.json` 25 26 ## Output 27 28 Write to stdout a JSON object with `claims_and_evidence` and `limitations_and_scope` keys, each containing checklist items with `applies`, `answer`, `justification`. 29 30 ## Rules 31 32 - Read schema descriptions in `schema/scan.schema.json` for detailed criteria. 33 - Use `applies` flags from triage.json. 34 - Be strict. Follow answer rules from `agents/scan-agent.md`. 35 - Cite specific sections/pages in justifications.